2nd bloom 1st year seedling. Ferncliff Dolly seed parent. The first bloom had a 9th petal and a couple deep petal splits so this 2nd bloom is definitely an improvement. The red streaks make it pretty cool in my opinion. The petal overlapping may be an issue. I have over 20 named collarettes growing and even some of the ones that routinely win at shows don't have perfect petal overlapping right now in my garden either, so maybe that is something that changes with weather, stress or other environmental factors. Or maybe this just isn't a keeper.
I'm bringing it to the Midwest show this weekend because they have a section for year 1 seedlings where you can get feedback from judges on whether to keep a seedling or not. I'm hoping to get some feedback that will help me should I continue to still try to grow a lot of collarette seedlings in the future. One pic with me shading it and one pic in full sun.